Sunday, 7 October 2012

Saxons bring up reinforcements

 As if the Romano-British haven't enough to worry about, this is a bunch of Gripping Beast Franks I  received in the mail this weekend.

Army in a box


Bought from Marktplaats/eBay with some unpainted stuff, including a box of Gripping Beast Anglo-Saxon thegn for the SAGA period. It was reasonable value for money. The painting is okay (although not as good as René). This means I now also have ample cavalry and skirmishers.

Considering I also have some great minis from Musketeer coming in, that about settles my army for this period.

And then I find out they do prepainted dark ages buildings from Gripping Beast and Warlord. That'll be my next objective then.

Thursday, 4 October 2012

More pics of my Saxons

Some more pictures of my Saxons. As said, they were painted excellently by René van den Assem. Check out his other work at his Paint_in weblog. Click on the images for close up.

A German warband

The gedrith or hearthguard, the close retainers of the lord
More gedrith


These will probably provide some of my named characters. You've got to love the dog minder and the shaman.


This is a warband of veteran warriors (duguth) in a linear formation with a fair bit of aggression


And finally a warband of duguth at ease


Now looking forward to my first game of Dux Britanniarum! I've been working on my main characters, who I will introduce to you soon.

Wednesday, 3 October 2012

Tannenberg, a no hope battle for the Russians

On my visit to London two weeks ago I was privileged to play with a group of veteran wargamers that Nick occassionally hangs out with. I got to play in a combination of a map campaign/miniatures tabletop battle devised by Ian Drury, who had interposed the scenario of the battle of Tannenberg in September 1914 over a set of early WWI miniature rules designed by Richard Brooks.

Some of you might be familiar with the (2nd) battle of Tannenberg in 1914. The 1st battle of Tannenberg was an ignominous defeat of the Teutonic Order at the hands of the Polish and Lithuanian nobility in 1410. In 1914 the Germans beat an invading Russian army in the same general area, but the mention of Tannenberg therefor had a much wider cultural significance for them. They had defeated the barbarian invaders.

As all corps were some distance apart at the outset and their positions not exactly known, we played the first few turns on the strategic map. When enemy troops were spotted, the action moved to the tables.

A Russian strategic map, 2 km to each square.
The white flags are corps HQs, green: infantry brigades
yellow and red: artillery, blue: spotted enemy formations
One of the excellent elements of the scenario was the flawless connection between map game and tabletop. Since the grids on the map were the same as on the table, there was no discussion about off map movement rates and appearances on table. This is certainly something I will remember for future map games.

The map game was played with OP14, an abstracted miniatures rule set, designed by Richard Brooks. Command was based on army corps, with brigades as the smallest units. A brigade effectively had four formation options, akin to Volley & Bayonet: march, deployed, defensive and basic field works. Basic field works had a chance of transforming into primitive trenches overnight.

Turns consituted one and a half ours of times and squares a square km. With a movement rate of 1 square per turn for deployed brigades and 2 squares for march formations. Units in deployed formation had an added chance of delay.

Our corps moving into a defensive position on day 1. 
Germans already dug in north of Tannenberg 

This was a tricky bit. Corps initiative was determined by a deck of cards. Low number had higher initiative, but the colour was important as well. All Russian corps were immobilised on spades, while brigades outside command radius were immobilised on diamonds. Any troops in rough terrain or crossing obstacles were delayed on clubs.

You can imagine the hardships Russian troops would suffer outside command range and in rough terrain. I never dared to try.

In combat the formation determined the amount of dice rolled by defenders, while the to hit level was determined by the amount of figures (4 per brigade, 2 or more for artillery). To make things interesting, troop quality determined what kind of dice you rolled, with elite troops rolling D6 and Landwehr rolling D10.

The abstractions worked really well at this level of command. There might even have been less, because matters of flanks in this historical period and tactical level might be ignored.


Now the Tannenberg scenario is obviously heavily skewed to the Germans. Not only do they have the knowledge of the terrain with added intelligence from airplanes and dirigibles, they also held the initiative and choice of the Schwerpunkt against a scattered opposition. Add to this the Russian immobilisation and lack of centralised command and the Russians were up for a serious thrashing.

Only thanks to hindsight the Russian commanders were able to limit the scale of disaster. Because we knew what was coming, we didn't attack deeper into the trap like the Russians did historically.


Alan and me had joint command of a Russian corps near the village of Tannenberg, with Alan doing communications and overall control and me doing the map dispositions. By the end of day one we had managed to put ourselves in a strong position, with dug in infantry supported by artillery and flanks based upon natural obstacles.

But there is a psychological difficulty to the defense that we could not surmount. As the Germans advanced on us on the second day, Alan decided that we should pull back in the light of overwhelming forces. While I agreed on the latter point, I was more worried about being outflanked, because I felt we could do a lot of damage in our defensive positions.

 
Our corps by the end of day 2, having got away from the Landwehr
This proved correct in hindsight as we were able to beat of a lot of German attacks when we pulled back from our position (there was a small amount of luck involved as well, but Napoleon nailed the point about lucky generals). Nevertheless we lost about half our command due to delayed movement and bottlenecks. Staying put might have ruined our corps, but done much more damage to our opponnents.



Anyway, falling back is a very difficult manoeuvre, especially when you have delays at crucial moments and rescuing half our corps was better than I had expected.

Overview of the battlefield by the end of day 2

There was also a nice system for combat exhaustion of corps. Once a unit received 25% losses, it drew a card from the deck. Any losses afterward required the draw of another card. If the value of this card was higher than those already drawn, the corps would be exhausted and unfit for offensive actions.

What I especially liked was to play two days of action in an afternoon with a good strategic feel. The only problem with the limited information was that as soon as units were put on the table, the were visible also for units far away. It might be advisable to have each corps fight its own battle on its own table, oblivious of what happened elsewhere.

Ian explaining afterwards what had happened off map. More bad news

Many thanks to Ian for putting this game on and to Richard for the ruleset. Ian's exlanation of what happened off map was very good in reminding us that even had we beaten off the Germans on our flank, other troops would have gotten into our rear and our fate was pretty much sealed. Made me feel much better about my crappy handling of the troops.

Tuesday, 2 October 2012

Making room on the shelves

I'm cleaning out my bookshelves. Does anybody want to save these books from the trash heap? 




West Point Military History Series: The Wars of Napoleon
A band of old issues of Uniformes, the French modelling and militaria magazine
Peaceful Action, a book of photographs from liberated Europe where western and Soviet troops met along what would later be known as the Iron Curtain.
The Armies of Britain 1485-1980, a long history of the British Army published by the Army Museum
Sociale Verdediging. Een kritische literatuurbeschouwing by Koen Koch


Drop a note in the comments and we'll arrange delivery. International is fine.
First come, first served.

Sunday, 30 September 2012

Succumbed to Descent 2nd Ed

Fell for Descent 2nd edition, especially because the conversion kit was there as well.




Descent 1st edition has been a bit of trouble, being sluggish. Descent 2nd ed. is to clear all that up and just lets you enjoy Dungeon Crawling. However, as the new Descent has new miniatures, you'll need the conversion kit to be able to use your 1st edition minis for 2nd edition. Yup, it's the FFG way.

Saturday, 29 September 2012

In gratitude to the Fates

Did some relaxing boardgaming yesterday. Two mediocre results for St Petersburg, a whooping win at Bohnanza (it helps to be generous) and a rare gift by the Fates in a game of Pickomino or Regenwormen, as we know it here.

I started out with the stunning opening of 37 points (notice these 8 dice have two sides effectively counting as 5). That gave me the highest tile in the game and after that I played a rather ruthless and defensive game. I was not going to self destruct as always. Not with this beauty!

Oh well, the Fates are fickle and for future gaming I won't count on Sister Luck handing me goodies again. I just put this one up for posterity. Much appreciated, Ladies!

And Mir, Mich and Died thanks for a.great night


Friday, 28 September 2012

First glimpse of my Saxons


Saxons are coming!
A quick snap of my newly painted figures. This was done with my not so great mobile, but I will do some better pictures with a better camera this weekend.

I am very pleased by the paint job René did, and I'll be happy to recommend his work to anyone. René really enhanced the already great sculpts of Gripping Beast.

In fact, these figures are not Saxons specific for Britain, but continental Germans. There's an overlap in miniatures between the two areas of course, but this gives my army a bit more identity.

Thursday, 27 September 2012

South of the DMZ - Vietnam Megagame Lost Youth


Last Saturday I took part in Lost Youth, the megagame on the Vietnam War designed by Jim Wallman. It was a small episode set during the early deployment of US troops, somewhere close to the DMZ, and as such it challenged many of the perceptions about this war. Our ideas of the drug ridden, gung ho US army are mostly based upon the later war and this turned out different.

The ground: open close to the DMZ, jungle to the south
The opposing forces

On the US-allied side there were four teams, an American and an Vietnamese army batallion, an American regimental command team and a press team. Their challenge was to coordinate their action while showing success towards the press and hiding the nastier side of war. They succeeded almost up to the end of the game.

The National Liberation Front consisted of three batallion teams led by a brigade HQ and a number of local cadres. These had their own, slightly lonely game in setting up booby traps and ammunition depots and maintaining local morale in the face of US activity.

The VC self criticism session. Note the red stars on the chest for ideological rigour!


Much fun was had on the NLF side during the two self criticism sessions, which didn't turn into with hunts but actually improved the planning and created a sense of united purpose. Umpires rewarded proper ideological composure and terminology.

As it happened

The scenario was a US batallion sized sweep through a a number of hamlets, which attracted a response by a Viet Cong regiment to hurt the Americans or at least take the heat of their local cadres. The US-allied forces used the main highway at the eastern edge of the map and of course helicopters to enter the map. The NLF entered from the southwest.

The US commander took a methodical approach, sweeping through open country near the DMZ while the VC decided on an attempt to draw them into an ambush in the wooded area. However, this was based on the false assumption that the US troops would drop all else to go on some kind of search and destroy mission. That didn't happen.

There's the batallion drawn up to attack the village

One of the Viet Cong batallions threatened the ARVN batalion in the southeastern corner of the map, guarding the highway, but drew no response. In a desperate attempt to force a reaction, the VC unit attacked, but by then the ARVN was well prepared and the attacked floundered unceremoniously.

By then the US troops had 'cleared' most of the open country (devastating one village under bombardment). As they prepared to move into the jungle, the VC hastily retreated.

The experience on the ground

As an operational staff officer in the VC batallion that got into the thick of it, I had an active, but straightforward day. We were first on the map and last to be off. If I say so myself I managed the approach march to the eastern edge of the map and the defensive deployment well. However, we had no orders to attack and we lost an oppportunity to attack on the first night as the ARVN were not yet dug in but this was also because of lack of preparation. Hasty attacks were not the NLF preferred option.

And that us after hurrying back to safety

By the end of the game we were set for a sharp rearguard action, covering the retreat of the other batallions, but given the presence of the ARVN batallion, this might not have ended at happily as we'd wish. The interesting picture is of course from the umpire map, showing the location of both sides and our supply status (yellow and white discs).

The umpire map shows the ARVN batallion following up... oops!

So how did it feel?

Feedback to the game was generally positive. Most players enjoyed the operational challenge and the ideological side of the game, even if for two VC batallions the day was a bit uneventfull. The local NLF cadres had difficulty in imposing themselves on the game and there was a tendency for the batallion players to focus on the military side at the expense of the local cadres.

Jim's idea is to do a number of follow up games set later in the war so players can develop some experience with asyymmetrical warfare, which is different from the set piece operational games we do more regularly.

There's a wealth of possibilities for scenarios, but maybe these are not all in the same time and ground scale. We now played on a very small battlefield (7x7 km) for three days of game time.

The umpire map: not many VC left on the map at the end


ps You might have missed the discussion the development of artillery around WWI at the Maximum Effort blog.

Sunday, 23 September 2012

The Feel of Napoleonic Battle: Le Feu Sacre


Yesterday was the first game of Le Feu Sacré in a long time. The rules were a bit rusty and there was some discussion, but this was all in good style. But it was a reason for me to dust of this older article and add a few new things I realised after playing again.


Le Feu Sacre is one of the many products running off the Too Fat Lardies' presses in the last few years. In general the miniature battle rule designs of this company are focussed on recreating the interesting challenges of warfare in particular era rather than providing balanced competition games. This means scenarios rather than points based army lists and command and control rather than troop types and armour specifications. To a historical gamer like me that is a huge plus.

The game is played at the corps level, with the main units being divisions although individual battalions are represented. Corps and divisional commanders, as well as the occasional detached brigadier, have a tactical ability (gifted, solid, poor) and character, with bold and cautious added to the mix.

Each division needs an order. An attack specifies an enemy formation or terrain objective to be attacked. This means that the troops generally have to move closer to the objective each turn and engage in firefight or charge at the earliest opportunity. A manoeuvre order allows more leeway in terms of movement, but only allows troops to engage when threatened or to support other divisions. The hold order requires the division to stay put and also limits its ability to attack.


The first change from the old fashioned rule sets is that units enter the table on 'blinds'. This means that the opponent doesn't know which units are where until he has 'spotted' the blinds. This becomes easier as the blinds get nearer and are in open rather than close terrain or behind other troops. Blinds can be in three formations: marching columns, half deployed and fully deployed. Marching column blinds move much faster, but when spotted the units start packed closely together and hardly able to defend themselves. The fully deployed blinds allow players to set up the units in a wider area and ready for battle. Of course there is the possibility of dummy blinds.

The traditional Igo-ugo and move-fire-melee-morale structures of the turn have been replaced by a card drawing system where each division has a card. When the unit's card is drawn, all its actions are resolved. Some cards are added to represent (grand) tactical characteristics of certain armies. The French armies in their heyday have a special card that allows the commander to move a division before its own card comes up, thus offering more opportunities. A card for bold commanders forces them to move before their own card comes up. A 'recon' card allows the blind of a light cavalry division or brigade to take an extra turn. This increases its speed and adds an extra opportunity to spot enemy blinds.

A division's turn consists of the commander rolling for PIPs (intervention points), one spotting attempt, bombardment and then all other actions. A gifted commander can score more PIPs than a poor one. One PIP may see a whole brigade execute the same order, or several PIPs may be used to have one unit execute a number of complicated manoeuvres. PIPs are also used to rally troops.


Small arms fire has been figured into the larger equation. Artillery and rifles can bombard enemy units. No figures are removed for casualties, so this requires some book keeping (we use small dice). In case of hits, the enemy is forced to take a morale test immediately.

Charges are still quite a complicated affair, but at least they are resolved straight away and counter charges and intercepts are dealt with at the same time. This means that no book keeping is required of charging units over the rest of the turn.

Similarly to small arms fire, the casualties of melee are not diced for, but come as the result of outcome of the total combat. That is, the winner and loser of the combat receive a set number of casualties. This also saves time compared to more traditional rule sets. Better still, combat involving multiple units on each side is still resolved with one die roll. This also speeds up melee considerably.



A final advantage of these rules is that they haven't fallen for the trap that British troops in line are unconquerable. A charge by several battalions in column will take out a line unless it is well supported. In this way good and historical tactics are rewarded.

So, there is a lot to like about these rules, and they seem to be an improvement on most rule sets available today. Also the game shifts the time from rolling for casualties (all the close combat is handled in one procedure) to matters of command an control, a preferable shift in my book.

Of course we haven´t played many games, so the rules are rusty, but the level of detail is a bit too high for my liking, especially the crucial rules about flanking and disorganisation. Admittedly, these are the most difficult rules to get right and their influence on the battle tends to be very high and visible.

When this is combined with the traditional wargamers' fault of too many troops in a cramped space, the game really slows down. In a IGO UGO ruleset at least you´re not waiting to see what the next unit is to move, and especially with a larger number of commands and players Le Feu Sacré doesn´t scale very well. My gut feeling now is to keep the number of units per player to 7 or 8 and above 10 it really starts to drag. More than 3 players per side also makes downtime too high.

And there's a further worry. Even the guys at Too Fat Lardies keep issuing new versions of their rules, with a tendency to increase complexity, rather than reducing it. By the end, we'll be in the same mess as with all the other rulesets.

This post was published in an earlier version on Fortress Ameritrash

Wednesday, 19 September 2012

Lost in the Western Desert



As they say: a darn good read! I picked it up at Skook books which rewarded me so well on my first visit this weekend.

The desert war has always fascinated me. It's the topography of the battlefields, as Barnett says, almost empty and therefor best suited for a clash of generalship. Here the operational genius of Rommel and O'Connor would stand out against the mediocrity of most others. But there's also the strategic side, the long distances and the logistic challenge (where Rommel showed less brilliance, perhaps, but which he tried to make up for with bluff and sheer willpower).

This book is not so much about the operational and strategic issues as about the character and ability of the commanders of the Eight Army and its predecessor, the Western Desert Force. Obviously, Barnett favours O'Connor and Auchinleck, while he writes Cunningham and Richie into the ground, even if with some sympathy.

But the venom is in the tail. Barnett's account of Montgomery's command is a textbook character assassination. After exposing him as a mean but before everything else a self publicising monomaniac who furthers his carreer at the expense of others (as opposed to modest men like O'Connor, Wavell and Auchinleck of course), he then destroys Monty's military reputation.

Not only (and this is Barnett speaking, not me) does Monty steal the good ideas for Alam Halfa and Alamein from Dorman-Smith and Auchinleck, he then also bungles the planning for Alamein (presumably counting on the effect that Rommel would have to withdraw anyway due to the Torch landings) and only saves it by superior resources and bloody single mindedness. He then finally fails to catch Rommel in pursuit. And at all times Barnett implicates that Montgomery tries to shift the blame and claim the glory.

In the appendices there's also an eulogy for Eric Dorman-Smith, obviously a highly talented, but non-conformist staff officer. Barnett sees him as the creative element during much of the successfull operations who was perfectly teamed with commanders like Wavell and Auchinleck, who appreciated his talents and knew how to employt them constructively.

However, after Auchinleck's removal, Dorman-Smith's carreer went downwards and at several times he was removed from commands. Barnett claims he was doing well in all those positions and that the reasons behind his repostings had to do with his intellectualism and intolerance for the mediocrity of others.

Whether or not this explanation is 100% correct I don't know, but there is clearly a pattern in the British army of WWII where visionary and intellectual officers (think also Hobart) lost out to more practical and especially more conformist ones.

Most surprising to me is that Wavell has no more prominent role in this book. While he maybe was always more than only a desert general, his presence in the background was highly influential in the first two years of the war. Barnett is generally favourable to Wavell.

Barnett is an excellent writer, despite his biases. I'm only now becoming aware of the factionalism in British military history writing, and it's still a bit fuzzy for me, but I get the impression that Barnett is part of the Liddell Hart group.

The problem for me is that I have always instinctively taken sides with O'Connor, Wavell (I even named him my favourite general) and Auchinleck. And Barnett's story of the bright elite losing out to the mediocre establishment makes them the natural underdog and plays on my self image as talented and non-conformist (Stop laughing, please!).

But I am also wary of totally discounting Montgomery's ability. He was obviously not a nice person to be associated with professionally, but he's always seemed solid to me. I've also grown suspicious of black and white characterisations.

So while enjoying this book very much, it leaves me not entirely convinced of the characterisations of the people involved.