Got a bit
frustrated with my lack of reading lately and so decided to take on some
lighter stuff, and Ospreys have proven excellent in that regard. Easy to pick
up and lay down on the commute.
First off
was King’s African Rifles vs Schutztruppe, continuing the theme of forgotten colonial wars.
Not a middle of the military history road subject. First of all it deals with an
African side show in World War I, when troops from British colonies tried to conquer the German colonies. And secondly, it prominently features the
African soldiers fighting the war.
And
compared to most Osprey books, there is more information on the non-western protagonists.
It is made clear that in the British units, with fewer white NCOs, more
responsibility devolved on the black NCOs especially when the (always white)
officers became casualties.
And the
author very cautiously treads the subject whether having more European NCOs was
better for battlefield performance. There are even a few passages from the
memoires of black participants.
On the
other hand, in the operational narrative, the perspective of the black soldiers
fades into the background. The prime actors there are the natural environment
dictating the tactical and strategic decisions made by white officers. And you
can still wonder how the askaris felt about fighting a colonial war.
On all the
other elements the book score above average. It does a good job of explaining the
challenges of bush warfare in southeastern Africa and the differences in
British and German policies towards war in Africa .
Also, the operational narrative is clear and highlights the most important
factors which are brought together in the final analysis. Special kudos for the
illustrations, which are very well integrated into the narrative, reinforcing
it with examples.
No comments:
Post a Comment
I appreciate comments. Let me know what you think!