I found the
book interesting for three reasons:
A Bold and Ambitious Enterprise tells
the story of a significant part of the army that would fight Napoleon at Quatre Bras and Waterloo a year
later. It was led by the aged but capable general Graham, who had served with Wellington in the Peninsula .
Its origins were not very fateful, cobbled together from units recovering and
rebuilding from service elsewhere. Many of the men were only partially trained
or otherwise unfit for service. It took time to gather enough strength to take
aggressive action, but in reality was unable to do so without support from
allied troops.
Although
the troops performed as well as might be expected in two small scale attacks against
the defences of Antwerp , the force failed its
toughest test: the storming of Bergen
op Zoom. This weak and isolated French garrison was a thorn in the flesh of the
allies, occupying troops that Graham wished to employ against his main
objective. The failure of the attack resulted mostly from insufficient troops
employed and failure of leadership by senior commanders. Some went off on their
own, thus leaving troops leaderless, other showed a lack of initiative. It all
ended in half of the forces killed, wounded or captured. All this bodes ill for
the performance a year later.
De Gevangenpoort or Prisoners Gate between the town centre and harbour A British section held out here until forced away in the morning |
The book also provides a counterpoint to the better known developments in
Finally, it has more
consideration for the position of Britain´s allies, ie the Dutch and Prussians,
than most British authors. This prevents the book from the all too familiar
blame game. Although Graham kept trying to get his allies to cooperate in a
move against Antwerp
(his main objective), it was understandable that their efforts were limited by
overriding considerations elsewhere. The book also shows that quite a few
people in prominent places during the Waterloo
campaign had already acquainted themselves with their allies and struck up a
workable relationship (eg Cooke, Bülow and Van Gorkum). That would prove
useful.
The book is
well written and makes good use of personal accounts. Although I didn’t care
much for the details of British involvement, it was nice to read about the
attack on Bergen
op Zoom, having visited the town in September. Too bad not much of the fortress
has remained.
No comments:
Post a Comment
I appreciate comments. Let me know what you think!